Better Than Yours: A Review of My Dad is the Best

My Dad is the Best
Fran Pintadera
Illustrated by Joan Turu
Charlesbridge
Ages 4-8
Available April 22, 2025

“My dad is the best.” “My dad is better!” This classic exchange sets off a back-and-forth of epic proportions between two little boys as they try to prove who really has the better dad. As their sons continue to one-up each other (“My dad can pick up a truck!” “My dad can pick up a truck filled with elephants!”) the two fathers do their best to keep up with the bigger and bigger demands being made of them. When everything comes crashing down and one dad helps the other, the boys move on from their competition. As it turns out – “My dad loves your dad.” and “My dad loves your dad, too.”

Equal parts silly and sweet, My Dad is the Best is a loveable take on a classic trope. The boys’ ridiculous demands drive the story, with each page adding another over-the-top detail. Turu’s illustrations play along, too, becoming larger and more complex as the dads’ task becomes bigger and stranger. Using a scribble-filled colored pencil style that’s simple yet effective, Turu packs each page full of emotion – whether it’s the pride of the boys watching their dads or the shock of each new feat wowing its audience. Once everything comes tumbling down (elephants, trucks, and all), the story shifts from an absurd competition to a more relaxed aftermath as the fight is forgotten. While everyone cleans up (and the elephants are safely escorted away), they discover that they get along alright, after all. The twist ending cements this story as a lovable subversion of the classic argument – one in which love, not competition, wins in the end.

Pintadera’s outrageous take on this competition heard in elementary schools the world over, combined with Turu’s charming illustrations, make for a story that’s sure to delight young readers. Whether they’re laughing at a truck full of elephants or “aww”-ing at the surprise ending, My Dad is the Best will keep picture book lovers excited and engaged.